Blog Post

Book Review: The Circle by Cindy Cipriano

Aime • February 11, 2020

An imaginative adaptation of one of the most enduring races of Irish folklore, the Sidhe.


That was fantastic!  Is the next book already out?




Those were my exact thoughts when I turned the last page of The Circle. From the first page, I was ensnared. I sat in my round chair all afternoon, with rampant FOMO on what happens next in the small town the Sidhe call home in our world. I was reluctant to put the iPad down and make dinner, and couldn't wait to settle in later that night to finish the tale—it was truly a fun read. 


Having spent time in Ireland studying folklore and history, I was already familiar with the Sidhe of legend, and Ms. Cipriano's modern twist is a wonderful adaptation. 


The story begins with the disappearance of one of three boy cousins as they play among the Sidhe and human worlds. We learn quickly that distance is not measured linearly, and passing between the realms is instantaneous. Some Sidhe have opted for leaving their mounds in favor of life in the human world, making a small North Carolina town their home instead. Calum's family is one of these, along with his cousin Hagen's family. They travel back and forth as they wish, and must, to keep their faerie powers strong.  



** I was given an ARC by the author, and I am extremely happy to post this review**
The protagonists in this story are 6th graders, (it has been classified as both Middle Grade Children's and Fantasy), but that does not restrict the story to a younger audience. Calum, Hagen, and their duine daonna (non-Sidhe) friend Laurel struggle through the school year, facing the usual trials of bullies, schoolwork, and emerging emotions, even as they discover they are all linked by the disappearances of their loved ones. Family bonds and trust are themes the trio must navigate as their respective pains bring them closer together, and to their goals.

One aspect of the story I enjoyed was Kenzie's Siopa Leabhar, the bookstore and cafe she runs in town. For some reason, I am always drawn to stories and book covers that feature bookstores. Most likely this is because a bookstore is one of my favorite places to be, but they are often places of stability, grounding, and constant for the characters in the stories. This one is no different. Kenzie's store is a fixture in the community; a place to stop in the morning for coffee, where the protagonists study, research, and plan, and where the Sidhe realm leaves its mark on our world in the verses encoded on its shelves. A bookstore that guides a patron to the answer to their questions? I'm in! Where do I enter? 

The author's writing style is engaging and descriptive; her merging of the human and Sidhe worlds is seamless. The magic draws on ancient lore, yet is injected with imaginative details that I truly marveled at. Several times I paused in my reading to appreciate the uniqueness of Ms. Cipriano's magic system. Such new idiosyncrasies gave the book a fresh feeling and left me dying to know what was next. 
 
 The Circle is not a 300+ page novel like I usually read, so I had the pleasure of finishing it in a day—which was perfect because I had a difficult time putting it down. The story moved at a lively pace, pulling the reader forward into the events with clear, modern dialogue that revealed plenty of details about the characters and their lives.
 I thoroughly enjoyed meeting each of the members of Calum's extended family, and keeping their lineages straight is part of the fun in a clan-based story such as this. Each character's persona is well-crafted and consistently reinforced by their actions. Some of the main story threads are resolved in this installment, but others are left open for the next, putting the second book, The Choice (out soon!) high on my TBR list.
 If you are a lover of Irish folklore-based fiction, I highly recommend The Circle. Sit down with a cup of tea on a rainy afternoon and you will hardly notice the time pass as The Circle carries you between this world and the mounds of the Sidhe. But beware! an hour you can only remain, in a mound not of your own clan. Happy reading!~ 
By Aime Sund April 1, 2024
Everyone has a thing that they prefer not to do, or see, or use, or hear.
By Aime Sund March 31, 2024
Either, but it depends on who or what is doing the impressing
By Aime Sund February 21, 2024
“I’ll be fine in the sun.” ~Dash
By Aime Sund February 20, 2024
Sometimes you just know...
By Aime Sund December 22, 2023
“It's time to go now.” - Dash
By Aime Sund December 22, 2023
What author hasn't asked this question of their computer screen, mirror,
By Aime Sund October 31, 2023
"You're not going without me." -Dash
By Aime Sund October 31, 2023
Is one POV better than another?
By Aime Sund September 23, 2023
A place to go to be grounded
By Aime Sund September 23, 2023
Does word order matter?
Show More
Share by: